A Look At The Hall of Fame Finalists 2024

Colorado Avalanche - TeeAloha

Every year when the finalists for the Pro Football Hall of Fame class are announced, it sparks eager debate among NFL fans. Which of these all-time greats will receive the highest individual honor in football – a bronze bust enshrined forever in Canton?

The 2024 list features several big names who have been here before, still patiently waiting their turn to don the coveted gold jacket. But leading the pack are two incredibly deserving first-year candidates Julius Peppers and Antonio Gates, who both have the resume to be first-ballot entries.

Peppers’ credentials are undeniable; with 159.5 career sacks, he is firmly cemented as one of the best pass rushers ever. Pair that with his longevity and consistency over 17 standout seasons, and he looks destined for induction this year.

Gates also boasts an impressive highlight reel from his time terrorizing defenses as an athletic, leaping tight end. While questions remain about his consistency, the numbers speak volumes – 116 touchdowns and over 11,000 yards from the TE spot.

In this post, we’ll analyze the case for these two legendary stars, as well as the chances for some veteran nominees hoping this year is finally their year. Strap in for a deep dive on the 2024 candidates – who has the stats and story to claim a place among the all-time greats?

The Hall of Fame decision is never easy, but this year’s class has some surefire names that belong among the best to ever play the game. Let the debate begin!

Many former great QBs could join these hopeful Hall of Famers like the best quarterbacks of all time.

How Finalists Are Chosen

Earning a bust in Canton is monumentally difficult – only the best of the best achieve football immortality. The selection process undertaken by the Pro Football Hall of Fame Committee reflects just how high the bar sits for entry.

Finalists first become eligible 5 years after hanging up their cleats. However, the separate Seniors Committee can nominate those retired over 25 seasons. But no matter how they get nominated, all finalists face the same daunting climb toward enshrinement.

The 48-person Selection Committee comprised of football media, former players and coaches, and front office executives receive the key task of poring over candidates. The debate and evaluation run deep as they measure accomplishments, impact, prestige and influence.

How Finalists Are Chosen Selection Committee – TeeAloha

It’s not just about flashy stats – postseason success, leadership qualities and overall football character all get weighed. The committee digs into game film, pores over record books, and analyzes nuanced contributions to determine who passes the eyebrow-raising bar for “remarkable and exceptional” careers.

In the final vote, the bar sits even higher – 80% approval means yes to immortality. The selective process leaves no doubt; those reaching football’s pantheon truly represent the best of the best.

The Complete List Of Pro Football Hall of Fame Finalists For 2024

Julius Peppers

At 6’7” and nearly 300 pounds, Julius Peppers was an athletic freak who terrorized quarterbacks with his explosive first step and overpowering strength. The 2002 Defensive Rookie of the Year, Peppers made an immediate impact for the Carolina Panthers with 12 sacks his first season.
Julius Peppers
He brought the heat year in and year out, leading the league in quarterback takedowns in 2004 and notching 10+ sacks in all but two seasons. Peppers sits fourth on the all-time sacks leaders list with 159.5 while being named to 9 Pro Bowls. With such sustained excellence rushing the passer, Peppers seems a shoo-in to don the gold jacket in 2024.

Antonio Gates

Antonio Gates revolutionized the modern tight end position with his blend of size, speed and leaping ability that he honed playing basketball. An elite red zone weapon, Gates used his boxing out skills and soft hands to notch an NFL record 116 touchdowns for the position.
Antonio Gates – TeeAloha
Gates hit paydirt at least 8 times in 7 different seasons, excelling with Philip Rivers in San Diego. His athleticism allowed him to tear down the seam and make contested catches over defenders. Though injuries slowed him late in his career, Gates’ status as the most productive receiving tight end ever makes him an intriguing first-ballot candidate.

Devin Hester

Simply put, Devin Hester is the greatest return specialist in NFL history. No one sent shockwaves through stadiums like Hester when fielding punts and kickoffs. His NFL record 20 total return touchdowns may never be broken thanks to his explosive acceleration and sharp cutback ability.
Devin Hester – TeeAloha
Few moments exemplify Hester’s excellence more than his 92-yard touchdown on the opening kickoff of Super Bowl 41. That score remains the only opening kick return for a TD in Super Bowl history. Hester’s aura in the return game resulted in clutch scores that flipped field position and energized his Bears teams. His Canton case is a compelling one.

This year’s list of finalists reads like a who’s who of football royalty. Stacked with legendary playmakers, ferocious pass rushers, and game-changing safeties, the class of 2024 represents some of the most dominant forces to ever take the gridiron.

Rodney Harrison

Rodney Harrison brought the thunder every time he roamed the secondary, earning a reputation as one of the hardest hitting safeties in NFL history. Harrison never shied from contact, instead delivering some of the most devastating blows the league has seen.

Rodney Harrison – TeeAloha

Despite his intimidating presence, Harrison also had a knack for making plays on the ball, hauling in 34 interceptions in his career. He helped anchor the back end of two Patriots Super Bowl championship teams in 2003 and 2004. Harrison played with an edge and tenacity that made receivers think twice before coming over the middle. His bone-rattling style of play makes him a compelling Hall of Fame candidate.

Torry Holt

A key cog in the St. Louis Rams’ prolific “Greatest Show on Turf” offense, wide receiver Torry Holt showcased elite route running skills and sure hands during his decade plus career. Selected to 7 Pro Bowls, Holt averaged over 90 catches, 1,300 yards and 7 touchdowns per season in his prime.

Torry Holt – TeeAloha

Playing alongside fellow star Isaac Bruce, Holt helped form one of the most feared receiving duos of his era. He led the NFL in receiving yards twice while winning a Super Bowl with the 1999 Rams. With gaudy stats and loads of accolades, Holt has the resume of a Hall of Fame pass catcher in waiting.

Andre Johnson

Though often stranded on lackluster Texans teams, wide receiver Andre Johnson shined brightly thanks to his impressive size/speed combo that he used to dominate opposing defensive backs. Johnson put up staggering numbers despite frequently erratic quarterback play in Houston.

Andre Johnson – TeeAloha

He topped 100 receptions twice and led the league in receiving yards in 2008 and 2009 – a remarkable feat given the Texans’ unsettled quarterback situation. The 7-time Pro Bowler was simply unguardable, blending physicality with graceful route running. Though ringless, Johnson has Hall of Fame credentials through his sustained statistical brilliance.

Willie Anderson

A mountain of a man at 6’5″, 340 pounds, offensive tackle Willie Anderson was an immovable object sealing the edge in pass protection for 13 stellar NFL seasons. Anderson played a crucial role paving rushing lanes during Corey Dillon’s franchise record-setting campaigns.

Willie Anderson – TeeAloha
Starting 167 of a possible 176 games, Anderson was a model of reliability for the Bengals. He earned three consecutive first-team All-Pro selections from 2004-2006, establishing himself as the AFC’s most dominant tackle. While Anderson’s career lacked playoff success, his individual excellence over a sustained period makes him an intriguing Hall of Fame candidate.

Jahri Evans

A bulldozer in the trenches, guard Jahri Evans spent over a decade bulldozing defenders in the interior for the New Orleans Saints. A fourth-round pick out of tiny Bloomsburg University, Evans soon became the fulcrum of New Orleans’ overpowering offensive line.

Jahri Evans – TeeAloha

He earned an eye-popping four straight first-team All-Pro selections from 2009-2012 while helping clear holes during the Saints’ Super Bowl run. Evans brought a nasty demeanor to drive defenders off the ball paired with impressive mobility pulling out in space. His individual prowess cementing the Saints’ line makes Evans more than deserving of Hall consideration.

Fred Taylor

In an era populated by the likes of Terrell Davis, Curtis Martin, and Edgerrin James, running back Fred Taylor still stood out thanks to his exceptional blend of size, speed, and power-churning out yards. When healthy, Taylor put together a spectacular stretch from 1998-2007 where he rushed for over 1,100 yards six times in seasons he played 13+ games.

Fred Taylor – TeeAloha

The long-time Jaguar led the NFL in rushing yards per game in 2000 while making one Pro Bowl appearance. Though he lacked some counting stats and postseason heroics, Taylor’s dominance when in the lineup makes him warrant of potential Hall of Fame enshrinement down the road.

Jared Allen

Jared Allen – TeeAloha

Hulking defensive end Jared Allen was a holy terror for opposing quarterbacks with his imposing mullet flowing out the back of his helmet. Allen authored a legendary 22-sack campaign in 2011 coming within half a sack of Michael Strahan’s single-season record. That tour de force campaign typified Allen’s relentlessness screaming off the edge with a lethal blend of power and finesse moves. Across 12 pro seasons, including 4 first-team All-Pro selections, the five-time Pro Bowler tallied 136 quarterback takedowns while being a one-man wrecking crew. Thanks to his penchant for living in opponent’s backfields, Allen is hoping a gold jacket soon awaits.

Dwight Freeney

Dwight Freeney – TeeAloha

Undersized pass rusher Dwight Freeney exceeded all expectations out of Syracuse, blossoming into one of the NFL’s most disruptive defensive forces for over a decade. Relying on explosive quickness turning the corner and a trademark spin move, Freeney gave offensive tackles nightmares. The Colts icon collected seven double-digit sack seasons, three first-team All-Pro nods and a Super Bowl ring during his fruitful career. In all, Freeney brought down quarterbacks on 125.5 occasions, earning a reputation as one of the league’s premier big-play bookends. His Canton case is compelling as one the early 21st century’s top havoc-wreaking sack artists.

Patrick Willis

Though his career was abruptly cut short after just 8 seasons, middle linebacker Patrick Willis left little doubt he was on a Hall of Fame trajectory from his first snap. Bursting onto the scene by capturing 2007 Defensive Rookie of the Year, Willis quickly emerged as one of the NFL’s most feared defenders with exceptional range and bone-rattling hitting ability.

Patrick Willis – TeeAloha

Despite hanging up his cleats at just 30, Willis earned Pro Bowl honors in each of his first seven seasons while garnering 5 first-team All-Pro selections – almost unprecedented accolades in such a short stretch. The lynchpin of several stout 49ers defenses, Willis brought athleticism and physicality to the linebacker position before injuries took their toll. But his first-ballot Hall credentials already make him one of the all-time greats of his era.


The 2024 Hall of Fame class is stacked with iconic talent who left an indelible imprint on football history, several looking destined for enshrinement in their first year on the ballot. Julius Peppers and Antonio Gates boast slam-dunk resumes packed with career records and sustained dominance, while returning candidates like bone-jarring safety Rodney Harrison and electric return specialist Devin Hester continue building strong cases. Whittling down to the few who clear the exceptionally high bar set by the stringent selection committee won’t be easy. But one thing remains certain – Canton will soon open its doors for several more all-time greats who achieved remarkable gridiron success through a mix of brilliance, longevity and leadership.